After reading chapters 2 and 3 in Critics – A Student Manual, I have a few thoughts.
To start, I learned that, really, the majority of us creatives feel the same way. We want our work to improve, and we want to discuss artwork… but we want it in a certain way. Obviously, we don’t want someone to completely degrade our work and our artistic style. We want conversations that are thoughtful, impactful, and provide a positive outlook. Now, this doesn’t mean that there would be no criticism/critique. We want others to note how we could improve, but we want it in an encouraging way. We want our work to feel appreciated and seen while also receiving ways we can make it even more impactful. We want the same thing.
This reading then pushed me to think about the characters of those that are providing the feedback and participating in the discussion. I always make it a goal of mine when taking part in a critique to always keep it positive and encouraging. I talk how I would want others to talk about my work. I like how the chapters mentioned the “Sandwich Method” and how that can be a positive thing to do, and I agree! But, it also makes me wonder if it’s a bad thing to only point out an area of growth in a work of art. There have been countless times where my work has been torn apart (it comes with the job, you learn to have thick skin). Now, was it always in the nicest way? Absolutely not. However, if someone only offers an area of growth in a positive and encouraging way, is that really a bad thing? Do you always have to include something positive? Aren’t you inherently pointing our something positive in the work itself by saying that it’s on the right path, or that it’s already good and that you’re suggesting a way to make it level up? This also makes me question if we as a human species are declining in comprehension and consideration for others. Why don’t you want to discuss the depths and meaning behind the artwork with the artist? Why wouldn’t you want to help someone improve their work? Kindness goes a long way.
So how do we combat this?
I honestly think about the lack of confidence that my generation has. I’ve experienced it, I have friends that experience it, and I’ve seen classmates experience it! We second guess ourselves and our thoughts and what we do that I honestly think it limits us from reaching out potential. Go out and try something! And if you fail, get back up! State your thoughts with confidence! You like something, say it! You don’t like something, say it with grace! I absolutely love the thought of a cat bringing a mouse continuously back to its owner, and it makes me think about the countless times my own cat has done that. Even despite us telling him to take it away or flinging it into the woods, he continues to bring something to us. We should be continuously bringing out work and thoughts forth to the world with confidence. We should embrace our uniqueness and areas of growth. It’s what makes us beautiful individuals.